Fraud stopped before payment: USD 750k+ saved on fake cardiac ablation claims

Case Studies
1 June

Case 1  ·  Claim Level  ·  Latin America

WHERE WE STARTED

One of Latin America’s largest national health insurers was processing high-value cardiac ablation claims from a hospital that had no cardiac ablation facilities. The claims passed standard validation — the procedure codes were legitimate, the amounts plausible. Nothing in the existing rules engine raised a flag. The fraud had been running for less than a year before Kirontech detected it — but in that time, claims were being settled automatically and without challenge.

THE CHALLENGE

Cardiac ablation is a complex, high-cost procedure used to correct abnormal heart rhythms — typically indicated in adults with specific arrhythmia diagnoses, rarely performed in patients under 18. The insurer’s existing rules-based engine checked for obvious red flags — duplicate claims, known exclusions — but had no way to assess whether a specific hospital was clinically capable of performing the procedures it was billing for, or whether the patients themselves were plausible candidates for those procedures.

What had already been tried:

The insurer’s fraud team had no existing workflow to cross-reference patient demographics, facility capability, and procedure frequency in combination. Each element looked normal in isolation — it was the pattern across them that revealed the scheme.

HOW KIRONTECH FOUND IT

  • HIP used multiple factors — age, location, time, cost, medical history, entity relationships — to assign a likelihood score to each procedure.
  • An ablation claim for a 17-year-old high school student triggered an immediate flag: cardiac ablation is almost never indicated in adolescents without a documented congenital condition, and this patient had no such history. The hospital also lacked the necessary facilities to perform the procedure.
  • HIP identified a second identical ablation claim with the same unusual features. Cross-referencing entity relationships revealed the doctor on the first claim was the father of the second patient.
  • Further analysis showed the patient in the original claim was actively at work on the date of the supposed treatment — corroborated through secondary data.
Insurer challengeOutcome & impact
Cardiac ablation billing looked legitimate in isolation — no single flag triggered existing rules. Hospital credentials were valid; nothing in the contract excluded the procedure. The fraud team had no mechanism to correlate patient demographics, facility capability and relationship networks simultaneously.Controls implemented to immediately reject further claims from this provider. Hospital suspended pending investigation. A reimbursement recovery process launched for previously settled claims. Total savings of USD 750k+ confirmed across the investigation. A new detection protocol established, now applied to similar claim patterns across the portfolio.

WHAT CHANGED

Beyond the financial recovery, this case changed how the insurer’s fraud team operates. For the first time, they had data-led evidence strong enough to suspend a provider and refer findings to their legal team. The detection model trained on this case now runs across all incoming high-value claims in the region — turning a one-off investigation into a standing capability.

THE RESULT

Fraudulent cardiac ablation claims intercepted before settlement. Hospital suspended. Patient shown to be at work, not at clinic. Total savings of USD 750k+ confirmed across the investigation.

Expertise and insight

Expert medical claims risk insight and case studies.
Image
Thought Leadership
2 June
Processing Claims does not FWA Management make.
Dr Simon Peck At a recent meeting, one of our clients said that many people do not understand the difference...
Image
Case Studies
2 June
USD 500k annual excess billing controlled at a leading dermatology clinic after 16 Mohs surgeries on one patient in 18 months
Case 3  ·  Provider Level  ·  Asia-Pacific WHERE WE STARTED A blue-chip dermatology clinic in the Asia-Pacific region was billing...
Image
Thought Leadership
2 June
Horses for Courses – Different Objectives of Clinical Coding
Dr Simon Peck In his book “Profiles of the Future: An Inquiry into the Limits of the Possible”, Arthur C....
Image
Case Studies
1 June
Eight per cent of a £24m claims spend identified as potential FWA — and the biggest risk wasn't fraud. It was chronic over-treatment hiding in mental health.
Case 7  ·  Employer Level  ·  United Kingdom WHERE WE STARTED A large UK employer — a household name —...
Image
Case Studies
1 June
23,635 spinal patients analysed: impossible procedure combinations and unsafe device use identified — public inquiry upheld findings
Case 6  ·  Country Level  ·  Australia WHERE WE STARTED Referred via a client partner, Kirontech was engaged to assist...
Image
Case Studies
1 June
Organised Crime Group identified and referred to police: £500k–£1m in dental fraud stopped before further losses
Case 5  ·  Collusion Level  ·  UK + International WHERE WE STARTED A large UK dental insurer was processing claims...
Image
Case Studies
1 June
EUR 2.5m+ saved annually as unnecessary knee and hip procedures challenged across an entire insurer portfolio
Case 4  ·  Policy Level  ·  Southern Europe WHERE WE STARTED A Southern European health insurer was processing high volumes...
Image
Case Studies
1 June
Intraoperative injury identified and actioned: third-party recovery pursued following complex pelvic surgery
Case 2  ·  Patient Level  ·  United Kingdom WHERE WE STARTED A UK private health insurer was processing claims for...
Image
Case Studies
1 June
Fraud stopped before payment: USD 750k+ saved on fake cardiac ablation claims
Case 1  ·  Claim Level  ·  Latin America WHERE WE STARTED One of Latin America’s largest national health insurers was...
Image
Thought Leadership
29 May
The Power of Soft Power: Stopping Waste and Abuse
Dr Simon Peck In https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/misconduct-health-insurance-fraud-does-matter-kirontech-uk-ltd/ we discussed the differences between various kinds of FWA (Fraud Waste and Abuse) in Health...
Image
Thought Leadership
29 May
The human element: managing FWA post-identification
In our previous bulletins, we discussed in some detail the identification of Fraud, Waste and Abuse (FWA) in health insurance...
Image
Thought Leadership
29 May
Blood Money – FWA in Pathology
Dr Simon Peck In his classic book “License to Steal – how Fraud Bleeds America’s Health Care System” Malcolm Sparrow...

Start your medical claims and payment risk intelligence journey

Tell us about your business, and we’ll show you where the opportunity sits.